Searchable Review Index

LATEST UPDATES


November
Book Pick
of the Month




November 15
New reviews in
The Book Nook,
The Illustrated Corner,
Nana's Nook, and
Odds & Ends and
Voices From the Past



November 1, 2026
Updated Convention Listings


October
Book Pick
of the Month




October 15
New reviews in
The Book Nook,
The Illustrated Corner,
Nana's Nook, and
Odds & Ends and
Voices From the Past



October 1, 2026
Updated Convention Listings


Previous Updates

WesternSFA


Engines of Reason
Elder Race Book II
by Adrian Tchaikovsky
Tor, $26.99 192pp
Publish date September 2026

It’s been five years since Book I was published, “Elder Race.”  I found that story to be very entertaining although it wasn’t on an epic scale.

To be honest, this wasn’t as profound as the first book.  The first book introduced some wonderful ideas that intrigued me.  This book did not introduce anything new, unfortunately.  In the first book review I did, I focused on the bigger concepts that had impressed me and I didn’t exactly fill in what was the real conflict: an otherworldly creature that wasn’t of Nyr’s technology nor was it of Lynesse’s world.  It confounded Nyr and to banish it, he was forced to give up one of his technological advances but he was okay with that since he decided to just try living his life.  He finds some satisfaction in teaching his knowledge to young people but he really only cares about one: Sara.  For her, he’d do anything.

Some bandits find an abandoned cave and eager for salvage, they find much more than they anticipated.  The leader, Sendra, finds technology that gives him control over ancient machines.  But, more importantly, he finds another Elder; and this one is interested in meeting Nyr and it doesn’t seem like she’s feeling very friendly.

Lynesse is doing her diplomatic duty for her sister when she meets Ilmoth Elder so she’s there when Nyr appears to investigate.  The two of them parted ways a year earlier and feelings are tender on both parts.  Nyr is intrigued by Ilmoth although it isn’t clear whether she is alien such as he or if she’s from Lynesse’s original ancestors.  She can control machines and she’s privy to information about Nyr’s origins that he hasn’t shared with anyone but Lyn.  But Ilmoth’s power isn’t enough against both Nyr and Lyn and she and the brigands are sent packing.

Lyn returns to court and Nyr to his tower.  Nyr is still reeling from meeting Ilmoth Elder and wants answers as to what she is.  Lyn is sent out again with instructions from her sister to use her diplomatic – and wizardly – skills to repair relations with other countries.  She heads directly to Nyr’s tower, with her daughter Sara in tow, to see if he has any information about Ilmoth or the brigands.

When Nyr gets back to his tower, he finds that Ilmoth got there first.  And, impossibly, was able to gain access to the interior and his computer systems.  She claims to be from Earth and demands access to his satellite to send a message there; anticipating an invasion force.  All of this is just so strange and illogical that Nyr can’t quite comprehend.  First of all, he no longer has access to the satellite, secondly, it’s been hundreds of years since contact with Earth and the idea that they would want to invade this little nothing of a world is ridiculous.  But the stakes become more significant when Lyn and Sara appear outside his tower and Ilmoth can use them to threaten him. 

The real mystery in the story is just what Ilmoth is and how she knows what she knows.  It becomes even more confusing when a DNA test of her blood – that she had to use to gain access to the tower – reveals that she is nothing more than a local woman; not an alien and not of the ancient humans from Earth.

Her origin and intent are directly related to the creature that Nyr banished from the world in the first book; a creature that he could not understand or define.  And his adopted world may continue to be threatened by this outside force if he can’t figure out what it is.  Worse is that Sara is directly affected and he doesn’t know if he has the technology to save her.

It was a decent plot but I did find the pace slow.  I didn’t feel that there was a big enough conflict; the author didn’t show what could happen if the creature got what it was after.  I felt concern for Sara but, again, nothing to contribute to dread or worry about the fate of anyone; it was rather vague.  Since there was no resolution, it’s possible this story will continue into another book. The end of the book hints that Nyr may have to contend with a creature that will have more power than him and he may be unable to protect his adopted home.  I’m rather ambivalent about it.  ~~  Catherine Book

For more titles by Adrian Tchaikovsky click here

Follow us

for notices on new content and events.
or

or
Instagram


to The Nameless Zine,
a publication of WesternSFA



WesternSFA
Main Page


Calendar
of Local Events


Disclaimer

Copyright ©2005-2026 All Rights Reserved
(Note that external links to guest web sites are not maintained by WesternSFA)
Comments, questions etc. email WebMaster